Minggu, 06 Januari 2013
Victim single; rape conviction tossed
California appeals court orders a retrial in a 2009 rape case Court cites 'historical anomalies' in an 1872 law and definition of rape The attorney general will seek to change 'arcane' law A man allegedly pretended to be an 18-year-old woman's boyfriend in a dark bedroom (CNN) -- California's top prosecutor will seek a change in an 1872 state law after an appeals court cited "historical anomalies in the law" when overturning a rape conviction of a man who allegedly pretended to be an 18-year-old woman's boyfriend in a dark bedroom. The appeals court ordered a retrial in the 2009 rape case. "This law is arcane and I will work with the Legislature to fix it," Attorney General Kamala D. Harris said in a statement Friday. "The evidence is clear that this case involved a nonconsensual assault that fits within the general understanding of what constitutes rape." Opinion: End culture of rape in 2013 This week, the California Court of Appeal overturned the rape conviction of Julio Morales, who was accused of raping an 18-year-old acquaintance after her boyfriend left the bedroom and she fell asleep. The court laid out the unusual circumstances of the case and problems in the 1872 law in the first paragraph of its ruling Wednesday: "A man enters the dark bedroom of an unmarried woman after seeing her boyfriend leave late at night, and has sexual intercourse with the woman while pretending to be the boyfriend," the court wrote. "Has the man committed rape? "Because of historical anomalies in the law and the statutory definition of rape, the answer is no, even though, if the woman had been married and the man had impersonated her husband, the answer would be yes," the court said. Debate over Violence Against Women Act centers on the vulnerable Los Angeles County prosecutors charged Morales with rape of an unconscious woman under the 1872 law, the court said. He was eventually convicted and sentenced to three years. During the trial, the jury was instructed that "[a] woman is unconscious of the nature of the act if she is unconscious or asleep or not aware that the act is occurring or not aware of the essential characteristics of the act because the perpetrator tricked, lied to, or concealed information from her." The prosecutor argued correctly that the 18-year-old woman was asleep, but argued incorrectly that the woman wasn't aware of the act due to Morales' alleged deception about being her boyfriend, the court said. In conflicting testimony, the defendant testified at one point that he told the woman he wasn't her boyfriend, the court said. "Because we cannot discern from this record whether the jury convicted defendant on the correct or incorrect theory, we must reverse," the court said. 'She could have been me': Action urged after Delhi gang rape case "We conclude that under the peculiar facts of this case, reversal is required because the prosecutor argued an incorrect theory of guilt, the instruction permitted the jury to convict on that theory, and the record does not permit us to find that the jury relied only on the prosecutor's correct theory," the court said. Morales' court-appointed attorney, Edward H. Schulman, said the retrial must omit the controversial instruction about an unconscious rape victim not being aware of "the essential characteristics of the act because the perpetrator tricked, lied to, or concealed information from her." The retrial would be Morales' third trial, Schulman told CNN. The first trial resulted in a hung jury, and the second convicted Morales, he said. Morales is now in his early 20s, the attorney said. State Assemblyman Katcho Achadjian said Friday that he will reintroduce legislation to close the loophole that resulted in the reversal. He first proposed such legislation last year after a woman in Santa Barbara County was raped in her bedroom. The woman first thought the attacker was her boyfriend and initially consented to sex. The county district attorney was unable to prosecute the man with felony rape. "Californians are justifiably outraged by this court ruling, and it is important that the Legislature join together to close whatever loopholes may exist in the law and uphold justice for rape victims," Achadjian said of the Morales case. Defense battles social media blizzard in Ohio rape case if(typeof CNN.expElements==='object'){CNN.expElements.init();} CNN's Stefan Simons contributed to this report.
Langganan:
Posting Komentar (Atom)
Arsip Blog
-
▼
2013
(377)
-
▼
Januari
(188)
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- SLAM! Wrestling Presents: The top stories of 2012
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- FAA grounds Boeing 787s to address risk of battery...
- Anderson Cooper Blasts Sandy Hook Conspiracy Theor...
- Eagles hire Chip Kelly as coach
- The top stories to watch in car racing this year
- Lance Armstrong doping confession: Who's involved?
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- U.S. election voted top story of 2012 by CBC readers
- Two dead in central London helicopter crash
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Sri Lankan lawyers denounce sacking of top judge
- Howard's return helps Lakers end 6-game skid
- Falcons fade, but still find way to beat Seahawks
- Howard's return helps Lakers end 6-game skid
- Top China Stories from WSJ: Air Pollution, Banks L...
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Double bagel as Sharapova powers into round two
- Luxury, sports cars in Detroit auto show spotlight
- The top stories to watch in car racing this year
- Thousands Protest in Moscow Against Ban on Adoptio...
- Top Canadian stories from the past week, plus othe...
- Top Ten Stories for January 5 through January 12
- Top ten stories of the week
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Miss New York wins Miss America pageant
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Miss New York wins Miss America pageant
- NHL, players' association officially end lockout
- The most popular stories on Canada.com in 2012
- Niners advance to NFC championship
- The most popular stories on Canada.com in 2012
- Top ten stories of the week
- Top ten stories of the week
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Details About Delhi Ra...
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Details About Delhi Ra...
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- N.Y. at forefront of gun-control fight
- Why the Feds opted for a sweeping safety review of...
- Dad predicts RGIII will be back for season opener
- Lance Armstrong Plans To Confess Doping Throughout...
- Apple CEO: China will be biggest market
- 46% of People Don't Know How Facebook Makes Money
- NBC's Gregory won't be charged for showing ammo ma...
- Luol Deng scores 33 as Bulls move to 3-0 vs. Knicks
- Jim Mora has contract extended
- Pakistani Shiites refuse to bury dead in protest a...
- Afghanistan Withdrawal: U.S. To Shift To Supportin...
- GOP looks for ways to stop the rape comments
- In whimsical retro tribute, Pac-Man appears on MIT...
- Man Arrested for Murder in Teen's Facebook-Reveale...
- Reid to Obama: OK to skip Congress on debt ceiling
- NBC’s Gregory won’t be charged for displaying ammu...
- Biden Wants Only Owners to Be Able to Shoot Guns
- First official portrait of Duchess of Cambridge un...
- School shooting at Taft High in California critica...
- Biden vows recommendations by Tuesday on curbing g...
- New York's Clean Tech Challenge To California
- California sheriff: Youth who shot classmate felt ...
- Obama, Karzai meeting to discuss ending Afghan war
- FAA to launch comprehensive review of Boeing 787
- W.H. gun plan: Out-organize the NRA
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Top 10 Stories On Zawya Dow Jones On Jan 10 At 080...
- Top China Stories from WSJ: Apple Meeting, Souther...
- GRAIN HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- KXLH Evening Top Stories - Thu Jan 10
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Kingfisher to Restart ...
- GRAIN HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- The Administration’s Case for Jack Lew
- Herbalife defense fails to convince investors
- Evidence suggests suspected killer James Holmes’ h...
- The Administration’s Case for Jack Lew
- Top 10 Stories On Zawya Dow Jones On Jan 10 At 080...
- PRECIOUS METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- Golden Globes Countdown! Anne Hathaway's Top 10 Re...
- Drug companies forge partnerships with top schools
- Michigan State Police looking for suspect who shot...
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Europe Shares Flat After Draghi Comments, Nokia Gains
- Death Of The Hedge Fund Short Seller
- Afghan Officials: Total US Troop Pullout Would Tri...
- Labor Secretary Hilda Solis resigns
- Yen Falls 2nd Day as Abe Urges BOJ on Inflation Ta...
- Ferry accident at Pier 11 injures dozens
- Biden: Obama exploring executive orders to combat ...
- Katherine Webb Denies Any Desire for BCS Fame
- At least 57 injured as ferry crashes into Manhatta...
- India Rape Should Prompt Police Reform Not Mob Reflex
- NEWS: At least 17 injuries, mostly minor, when fer...
- Captured deep beneath the waves: Giant squid filme...
- Authorities testify how Colorado gunman aimed to k...
- Why 'Django' stirs race debate
- National Cathedral to wed same-sex couples
- Mom yanks python off sleeping tot
- State lawsuit against NCAA is absurd
-
▼
Januari
(188)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar