Rabu, 09 Januari 2013
State lawsuit against NCAA is absurd
Gov. Tom Corbett filed a lawsuit against NCAA over sanctions on Penn State Jeffrey Standen: The lawsuit is smart politically, but makes no sense legally He says complaint reads less like a legal document, more like a press release Standen: Even if lawsuit were successful, NCAA can reopen the case Editor's note: Jeffrey Standen is the Van Winkle Melton professor of sports law at Willamette University in Oregon. (CNN) -- The federal lawsuit filed by Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett on behalf of the state against the NCAA is politically smart. It is never a bad thing for a state lawmaker to stand behind the flagship university, especially when the lawmaker himself is under investigation for his alleged complicity in protracting the official inquiry of Jerry Sandusky. But legally, the lawsuit makes no sense. Recall the events: Penn State University, in the midst of the national scandal stemming from the crimes of Sandusky, agreed to settle any claims that the NCAA might have against it for failure to supervise its football program. The settlement was undeniably harsh, including a fine of $60 million, loss of scholarships and bowl eligibility for four years, and the easing of rules to allow student-athletes to transfer out of Penn State's football program. (Meanwhile, outside of the settlement, the criminal trials of key university administrators for perjury and failure to report abuse are proceeding.) Jeffrey Standen Like most plea bargains, the perpetrator got something from the deal, too. By settling early, the university avoided the prolonged NCAA infractions process. Proceeding by the infractions process would have kept Penn State's name, Sandusky's crimes and Joe Paterno's dubious legacy in the news longer than usual. More alarmingly, the infractions committee could have imposed the dreaded "death penalty" -- a complete termination of the football program for years, the cost of which would have undoubtedly dwarfed the measures imposed. Notably, Penn State agreed in accepting the deal that it would not challenge the NCAA's authority in court. Become a fan of CNNOpinion Stay up to date on the latest opinion, analysis and conversations through social media. Join us at Facebook/CNNOpinion and follow us @CNNOpinion on Twitter. We welcome your ideas and comments. Corbett described the sanctions as "overreaching and unlawful" while other lawmakers object to the fines being used to fund programs in other states. Since the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania was not limited by the Penn State-NCAA agreement, it can sue to overturn it. Yet it is that very fact -- that Pennsylvania is a stranger to the agreement -- that dooms its litigation. The lawsuit asks the court to grant an injunction so that NCAA can be refrained from imposing the sanctions. Injunctions look to the future and are designed to prevent damages. Typically, an injunction plaintiff claims that something bad is about to happen and asks the court to stop it. What bad thing will happen to Pennsylvania? It partially funds Penn State. Therefore, according to the complaint, future NCAA sanctions that come out of the Penn State treasury will, by derivation, also be taken from Pennsylvania's treasury, or at least the part of it that the state chooses to share with the university. var currExpandable="expand110"; if(typeof CNN.expandableMap==='object'){CNN.expandableMap.push(currExpandable);} var mObj={}; mObj.type='video'; mObj.contentId=''; mObj.source='bestoftv/2013/01/03/exp-point-corbett-ncaa-lawsuit.cnn'; mObj.videoSource='CNN'; mObj.videoSourceUrl=''; mObj.lgImage="http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/dam/assets/130103024211-exp-point-corbett-ncaa-lawsuit-00002001-story-body.jpg"; mObj.lgImageX=300; mObj.lgImageY=169; mObj.origImageX="214"; mObj.origImageY="120"; mObj.contentType='video'; CNN.expElements.expand110Store=mObj; Berman to Corbett: Football came first var currExpandable="expand210"; if(typeof CNN.expandableMap==='object'){CNN.expandableMap.push(currExpandable);} var mObj={}; mObj.type='video'; mObj.contentId=''; mObj.source='us/2013/01/03/brooke-penn-gov-sues-ncaa.cnn'; mObj.videoSource='CNN'; mObj.videoSourceUrl=''; mObj.lgImage="http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/dam/assets/130103010824-brooke-penn-gov-sues-ncaa-00032211-story-body.jpg"; mObj.lgImageX=300; mObj.lgImageY=169; mObj.origImageX="214"; mObj.origImageY="120"; mObj.contentType='video'; CNN.expElements.expand210Store=mObj; Pennsylvania sues NCAA over sanctions var currExpandable="expand310"; if(typeof CNN.expandableMap==='object'){CNN.expandableMap.push(currExpandable);} var mObj={}; mObj.type='video'; mObj.contentId=''; mObj.source='us/2013/01/02/nr-pa-gov-tom-corbett-ncaa-penn-state-sanctions.cnn'; mObj.videoSource='CNN'; mObj.videoSourceUrl='http://newsroom.blogs.cnn.com/'; mObj.lgImage="http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/dam/assets/130102013845-tom-corbett-pennsylvania-story-body.jpg"; mObj.lgImageX=300; mObj.lgImageY=169; mObj.origImageX="214"; mObj.origImageY="120"; mObj.contentType='video'; CNN.expElements.expand310Store=mObj; Gov. sues NCAA over Penn State sanctions In other words, Pennsylvania is claiming that it will be injured by its decision to contribute money to the university. If it is so keen to prevent itself from being harmed, why doesn't the state simply refuse to give money to the school until the sanctions period has expired? Pennsylvania will not be injured by the NCAA's sanctions; it will be injured by its own decision to fund the university. No federal judge is going to find otherwise. I strongly suspect Pennsylvania's lawyers are well aware of the fundamental absurdity of their lawsuit. That is why the complaint repeatedly alludes to the losses that other people and parties will suffer from the NCAA sanctions; those others include local businesses, other students and sports teams at the university, season-ticket holders and the numerous merchandise vendors who profit from the financial success of this greatest-of-all revenue sports. Yet none of those other people would likely have standing to sue, so their inclusion only underscores the state's untenable litigation position. At times, the complaint filed by the state reads less like a legal document and more like a press release, extolling the fine virtues of a Penn State education amidst the hard-working townsfolk of central Pennsylvania. The complaint also strangely paints the NCAA in starkly negative hues, as if associating the organization with greed and its leadership with conspiracy will somehow make a difference. It goes so far as to smear the NCAA president for his handsome salary, noting that it constitutes a substantial raise over that of his predecessor. This lawsuit will probably not get past the motion to dismiss. The high point of the suit in Pennsylvania's eyes is now; get your shots in while you can. But imagine that Pennsylvania actually litigates to a successful conclusion and has the consent decree between Penn State and the NCAA overturned. What then? The NCAA can simply reopen the case and refer the matter to the infractions process, with the penalty of death the likely outcome for Penn State's Nittany Lions. If Joe were still here, he would tell you: Sometimes it's smarter to punt. Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion if(typeof CNN.expElements==='object'){CNN.expElements.init();} The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Jeffrey Standen.
Langganan:
Posting Komentar (Atom)
Arsip Blog
-
▼
2013
(377)
-
▼
Januari
(188)
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- SLAM! Wrestling Presents: The top stories of 2012
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- FAA grounds Boeing 787s to address risk of battery...
- Anderson Cooper Blasts Sandy Hook Conspiracy Theor...
- Eagles hire Chip Kelly as coach
- The top stories to watch in car racing this year
- Lance Armstrong doping confession: Who's involved?
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Stories Of The Day
- U.S. election voted top story of 2012 by CBC readers
- Two dead in central London helicopter crash
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- SOFTS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Sri Lankan lawyers denounce sacking of top judge
- Howard's return helps Lakers end 6-game skid
- Falcons fade, but still find way to beat Seahawks
- Howard's return helps Lakers end 6-game skid
- Top China Stories from WSJ: Air Pollution, Banks L...
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Double bagel as Sharapova powers into round two
- Luxury, sports cars in Detroit auto show spotlight
- The top stories to watch in car racing this year
- Thousands Protest in Moscow Against Ban on Adoptio...
- Top Canadian stories from the past week, plus othe...
- Top Ten Stories for January 5 through January 12
- Top ten stories of the week
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Miss New York wins Miss America pageant
- Africa: Top 5 stories of the week
- Miss New York wins Miss America pageant
- NHL, players' association officially end lockout
- The most popular stories on Canada.com in 2012
- Niners advance to NFC championship
- The most popular stories on Canada.com in 2012
- Top ten stories of the week
- Top ten stories of the week
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Details About Delhi Ra...
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Details About Delhi Ra...
- BASE METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories Of The Day
- N.Y. at forefront of gun-control fight
- Why the Feds opted for a sweeping safety review of...
- Dad predicts RGIII will be back for season opener
- Lance Armstrong Plans To Confess Doping Throughout...
- Apple CEO: China will be biggest market
- 46% of People Don't Know How Facebook Makes Money
- NBC's Gregory won't be charged for showing ammo ma...
- Luol Deng scores 33 as Bulls move to 3-0 vs. Knicks
- Jim Mora has contract extended
- Pakistani Shiites refuse to bury dead in protest a...
- Afghanistan Withdrawal: U.S. To Shift To Supportin...
- GOP looks for ways to stop the rape comments
- In whimsical retro tribute, Pac-Man appears on MIT...
- Man Arrested for Murder in Teen's Facebook-Reveale...
- Reid to Obama: OK to skip Congress on debt ceiling
- NBC’s Gregory won’t be charged for displaying ammu...
- Biden Wants Only Owners to Be Able to Shoot Guns
- First official portrait of Duchess of Cambridge un...
- School shooting at Taft High in California critica...
- Biden vows recommendations by Tuesday on curbing g...
- New York's Clean Tech Challenge To California
- California sheriff: Youth who shot classmate felt ...
- Obama, Karzai meeting to discuss ending Afghan war
- FAA to launch comprehensive review of Boeing 787
- W.H. gun plan: Out-organize the NRA
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Top 10 Stories On Zawya Dow Jones On Jan 10 At 080...
- Top China Stories from WSJ: Apple Meeting, Souther...
- GRAIN HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- KXLH Evening Top Stories - Thu Jan 10
- Top India Stories From WSJ: Kingfisher to Restart ...
- GRAIN HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- The Administration’s Case for Jack Lew
- Herbalife defense fails to convince investors
- Evidence suggests suspected killer James Holmes’ h...
- The Administration’s Case for Jack Lew
- Top 10 Stories On Zawya Dow Jones On Jan 10 At 080...
- PRECIOUS METALS HIGHLIGHTS: Top Stories of the Day
- Golden Globes Countdown! Anne Hathaway's Top 10 Re...
- Drug companies forge partnerships with top schools
- Michigan State Police looking for suspect who shot...
- Media censorship: Top censored stories of 2012
- Europe Shares Flat After Draghi Comments, Nokia Gains
- Death Of The Hedge Fund Short Seller
- Afghan Officials: Total US Troop Pullout Would Tri...
- Labor Secretary Hilda Solis resigns
- Yen Falls 2nd Day as Abe Urges BOJ on Inflation Ta...
- Ferry accident at Pier 11 injures dozens
- Biden: Obama exploring executive orders to combat ...
- Katherine Webb Denies Any Desire for BCS Fame
- At least 57 injured as ferry crashes into Manhatta...
- India Rape Should Prompt Police Reform Not Mob Reflex
- NEWS: At least 17 injuries, mostly minor, when fer...
- Captured deep beneath the waves: Giant squid filme...
- Authorities testify how Colorado gunman aimed to k...
- Why 'Django' stirs race debate
- National Cathedral to wed same-sex couples
- Mom yanks python off sleeping tot
- State lawsuit against NCAA is absurd
-
▼
Januari
(188)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar